the old man
woken from sleep remembers
he has 10 great-grand kids

Published by

Patricia Prime

Patricia has recently retired from teaching after 30 years, and now devotes some time to the reading recovery programme at her local school. She is the co-editor of the New Zealand haiku magazine Kokako and reviews editor of the online magazine Stylus. She writes short stories, poetry, reviews and articles, and likes to write collaborative poems with other poets. Contact Patricia: pprime at ihug.co.nz.

121 thoughts on “”

  1. perhaps, clearing my throat, at this point in time, might soften my words, even enough for me, while enduring what i am about to say.
    first, i reread the artist’s piece, and again…

    “the old man
    woken from sleep remembers
    he has 10 great-grand kids”

    what can i really say, for this says it all. even to the point of saying too much.

    there isn’t that “hint” of mystery one normally connects to a haiku.

    well, let’s see what we have here, line by line.

    “the” in the first line is even too much.

    second line, had potential, but simply said it all for us, rather than test our imagination.

    third line, oops, what’s going on here, great-grand kids, you don’t say.

    now what???

    remake in order.

    old man reposed
    dreaming, for real, or ideal…
    great-grand kids squeals

    but, hey, what do i know…

  2. In reply to Bob’s rewriting my poem:”old man reposed” – real people don’t talk like that! “dreaming, for real, or ideal” – too intellectual, you’re giving us ideas, “”great-grand kids squeals” – they were not there with him. The old man(93)woke up to reality from a deep sleep, but is still able to remember that he has 10 great-grand children.

  3. in response to patricia’s response, it may have seemed i was rewriting your piece, but that’s not true. what i was attempting to do was build upon your idea as i interpreted it, which resulted in your enlightening me, well worth the effort i think.
    secondly, i do believe i am real, as are you. to say “real people” do not talk in this manner, this i ponder. perhaps you meant something with a different meaning; akin to a certain amount of individual wouldn’t conceivably understand the words i used, but real never the less. some real people would, some real people wouldn’t understand.

    thirdly, a haiku is designed to give one “ideas”, there-in is it’s appeal.

    to be cont.

  4. before continuing, an apology to dft and the readers of this site, for my being “wordy”…

    in continuing:

    patricia, fourthly, in reading any haiku, how many “real people” are there to experience the event…

    fifthly, “i think real people are more intellectual than you give us credit for.

    sixthly, any real person upon awakening from a repose or “deep sleep” (for the real people), takes a moment to gather one’s senses, then “remembers” who they are, where they are, and what is the situation surrounding their hours of being awake, while still wondering if the situation before them is for real.

    seventhly, in rereading my words, i wondered what you may have missed in them.

    to be continued…

  5. in continuing, for i almost there…

    eighthly, i gave you applauds for producing a stirring piece, but in it’s finished form, i felt it was a story being told, rather than being in pure or even hybrid haiku form.

    i appreciate your response, and i sincerely desire it doesn’t end here, for it is worthy of further discussion.

    though as i said previously, “what do i know”, other than i am real, and even that is questioned by some.

  6. Bob, thanks for the lengths you’ve gone to in discussing my poem. I still think it’s a very deep poem and has lots of emotional overtones and deeper layers of meaning than one can read into it at first – the sign of a “good” poem?? I think the old man saga is finished now. Look for some new stuff coming up from New Zealand!!

  7. hello, again, patricia,
    it has been my pleasure.
    my thoughts are, any piece worth writing is worthy of lengthy discussion. alas, the word individualism comes to mind. who among us think precisely the same, or can agree on most things.

    i am not debating your writings being deep, nor carrying deep overtones, nor possessing deep meanings, however, within the frame works of the haiku, there is required from the artist’s work a hinting of the inroads which are intended to nudge one in that/those directions. as in any haiku, those paths are many, depending upon one’s perception and another’s precept.

    i look forward to the “new stuff coming out and up from new zealand”, may they be just as challenging.
    i was elated by your response to my initial comments. who can accurately point out the little intricacies of one’s creation better than the “Creator”…

  8. funny thought, “i wonder if patricia is going to allow me to have the last word…”

  9. Thanks Patricia for this unusual Haiku.

    two old men
    greet each other again
    with their canes~

    “see you tomorrow”
    John eighty-eight to
    Ram well past ninety~

    the dead don’t die~
    they go elsewhere make
    their new cosmic-cages~

  10. Hi, haiku lovers. My response to Bob and Narayanan:

    seventy years
    he held her . . . still holds her
    and the wreath she carries

    Love, Patricia

  11. i think patricia loves to hold me suspended

    ===

    empty arms …
    present needs
    albeit, memories fail to fill the void

    eternally

    just me

  12. Bob, liked the idea. Thought it could be honed a little. Suggest:

    empty arms . . .
    present needs
    as memory fails

  13. kind lady,
    inspirational behind my smile; i was not referring to a failure of memory, but the inability of memories to take the place of the “real thing”

    grey spanish moss
    between the green oak leaves –
    lucent sunday morning

  14. brisk winds ~
    silence,
    where do the birds go, bad weather comes

    trees sway
    raptures circling …
    faster and faster

  15. ruru
    large yellow eyes, high piercing call —
    out of the darkness

    bad news
    come twilight —

    good news

  16. almost
    not nearly enough —
    then, we’re gone

    each day quickens –
    the seedling
    now, the mighty oak

  17. pathological –
    nobody, nobody, nobody

    knows

    patricia, such a haunting piece, resembling one’s midnight walks.

    often rumored, poets die young.
    strange, though fascinating, where one’s inspirations come from

  18. good evening patricia(or perchance morning)
    your thoughts of autumn jarred me into rememberance; albeit spring here, autumn finds you there.

    again, gold in arrowtown
    this third season —
    of my loneliness

    eternally

    just me

Your response: